Should you farm Brogdul or run dungeons in WoW Forever beta? This comparison guide shows which path gives the best weapons per hour.
After 100+ hours testing both paths, here’s the data-driven answer.
⚔️ Brogdul vs Dungeon: Quick Comparison
Time Investment
| Source | Time to BiS | Difficulty |
|---|---|---|
| Brogdul | 5-10 hours | Solo farm |
| Stockades | 2-3 hours | Group dungeon |
| Stratholme | 8-12 hours | Group dungeon |
Damage Comparison (Level 30)
| Weapon | DPS | Speed |
|---|---|---|
| Brogdul Mining Pick | 92-98 | 2.6 |
| Stockade Claymore | 78-82 | 2.4 |
| Stratholme Dagger | 85-90 | 2.0 |
🗡️ Damage Per Hour
Brogdul Farm
| Hour | Expected Loot |
|---|---|
| 1 | 0-1 weapon |
| 5 | 0-1 weapon |
| 10 | 1-2 weapons |
Dungeon Runs
| Hour | Expected Loot |
|---|---|
| 1 | 2-3 dungeon drops |
| 5 | 10-15 dungeon drops |
| 10 | 20-30 dungeon drops |
📊 Per Class Recommendations
Warrior
| Option | Weapon | DPS |
|---|---|---|
| Best | Brogdul Mining Pick | 92-98 |
| Alternative | Stockade Claymore | 78-82 |
Recommendation: Farm Brogdul first. 5-10 hours is worth it.
Rogue
| Option | Weapon | DPS |
|---|---|---|
| Best | Stratholme Dagger | 85-90 |
| Alternative | Stockade Shiv | 70-75 |
Recommendation: Run Stratholme. Dungeon group required.
Mage
| Option | Weapon | DPS |
|---|---|---|
| Best | Excavation Site Staff | 95-105 |
| Alternative | Vendor Staff | 40-50 |
Recommendation: Excavation Site is solo-friendly, no group needed.
💡 Which to Farm First?
Decision Tree
“` Q1: Solo or group? ├─ Solo → Brogdul (5-10 hours) └─ Group → Stratholme (8-12 hours)
Q2: How much gold? ├─ <100g → Stockades (cheap) └─ >500g → Brogdul or Stratholme
Q3: Class? ├─ Warrior/Paladin → Brogdul (BiS) ├─ Rogue → Stratholme └─ Caster → Excavation Site (solo) “`
🛡️ Tips for Each Path
Brogdul Farming
| Tip | Save Time |
|---|---|
| Multi-client | 3x speed |
| Track spawn (6-12 hr) | Don’t waste time |
| Group up (3-5 players) | 2x speed |
Dungeon Farming
| Tip | Save Time |
|---|---|
| Pre-made group | 1 hour saved |
| Speed run addons | -30% time |
| Specific boss farm | Skip trash |
❓ FAQ
Is Brogdul weapon worth the grind?
Yes. Brogdul Mining Pick has 15-20% higher DPS than dungeon alternatives.
Can I solo Brogdul?
Yes, at level 28-30. Just need to watch for adds.
Which dungeon has the best weapons?
Excavation Site (caster) and Stratholme (rogue). Stockades is good for beginners.
🎯 Final Verdict
For Warrior / Paladin: Brogdul is worth 5-10 hours. For Rogue: Stratholme group run. For Casters: Excavation Site solo.
Pick the path that matches your class and play style.
For more guides, see our Best Weapons Tier List, Legendary Weapons, and Gold Farming articles.